A fundamental issue identified in these meetings is the question of our planting locations which <br /> put trees in the way of construction, as well as the impact that trees have on other infrastructure. <br /> Is the right -of -way the best place to put trees that, in the future, may be harmed by our need to <br /> repair or replace streets, sidewalks, storm and wastewater systems, or utilities? The <br /> consequences are twofold because not only are trees affected, but the built infrastructure is <br /> affected by the trees, as roots lift up nearby streets and sidewalks, creating tripping hazards and <br /> repair work, and plugging and breaking sewers and drain lines. <br /> Another problem the Team wrestled with was the idea of limits — how much money are we <br /> willing to spend to design and construct around, and mitigate for trees identified for preservation <br /> or to enhance tree planting? Should we reduce any structural integrity or intended purpose of the <br /> built infrastructure to preserve trees? <br /> For the PEPI process, discussion centered on trees on the edge of the ROW on private property. <br /> Since the land use stage is conceptual, we often don't know where the utilities will be located <br /> exactly (width, depth of ROW). We can't defer the tree preservation plan, which identifies the <br /> trees to be protected, though some trees on private property are not shown. <br /> Conclusions <br /> The Team was able to achieve agreement on many issues put forth as part of this project. For <br /> instance: <br /> 1) Involving the Urban Forester's Office early in the scoping and design processes <br /> promotes teamwork and good decision - making. <br /> 2) The use of outside arborists will be managed by the Urban Forester's Office to <br /> increase consistency. <br /> 3) For projects with significant tree impacts, the Urban Forestry staff will become <br /> part of the design team, attending internal meetings and having frequent <br /> discussions, as well as explaining tree impacts to community members. <br /> 4) When exploratory excavation occurs (to determine root locations so that the <br /> Urban Forestry staff can estimate the impacts of proposed construction on tree <br /> roots), it will be done during design as much as possible. Root locations should <br /> be known before construction begins. <br /> 5) In general, with property owner's concurrence, trees outside the ROW on private <br /> property that may experience root impacts will be evaluated for conditions and <br /> root locations, and measures will be taken to protect and mitigate damage to these <br /> trees. <br /> 6) For all projects, efforts will be made to preserve existing trees unless those <br /> efforts cost more than the tree(s)' appraisal value (i.e., Is the cost of the design <br /> and construction change less than the value of the tree ?). For street construction <br /> 4 <br />