|
Record of Decision Attachment C -Agency Comment and Responses
<br />,.n~~i :660of the Chigtiita site. The result oEchis investigation confiimedca.liu: ~tiTdies
<br />((-1~ ; i ty92; ScientecU7949} thattncidentalpetroleum cgntaminationispresant is e irf~ri 's
<br />a.' various Iocafiona prigtarily acrosstHewesteniporiionofllteproperty. Herne- co: ~. uc;, t]_Irt
<br />!ihcringofth~graundµ!atersamplcs'obraincdaridanalyticalresttltsdidnotntd~:a:~_u ~..i~'-,
<br />metalcontarfiinationingoundwatec:IIothfheScientee~l~~~4andlierrera26('(?in;r ~,_uii~>>L
<br />santplcdgntpndwatr~..r'li~whonsinthewe^!em'portioit:,uithepropei-ty,r '~n,lkr,!°~~~.i,
<br />compomids,(VOCsj i7~~_presenceofVOCscmtnften6euttributedtoth ,. ~ :r;i~aisu~,
<br />solvents acid d~~reas~r~. thcrawere no VGc.~ udcotul during the bRnun.ti.a,cx Dpurprti+$ uy
<br />efiher of fhe investigations. There wero soma excnvatad auger pmbas done to the vv~st crf [Ire
<br />ALnvCraftbuildutg as poet of a f'ulhtral ResottiY:es rapod`prepaced by I?VFOTECResenrch far
<br />~1~OP in 1'Jl2_ Thercisno evidence that ipciicatesWidt precut envirorimenutltiestiassfromt~e
<br />,1~ ~ C'- 1L site. 7'lae EI'cireta Phase I dated July.2t300 Tei~iewad the Underground Fnel Tank
<br />Fxrr~~alClosurekeparc(LnmhierStevensonl9B8). Ihatreportdetailedthexcmovaloftwo ;~
<br />ur ~ i „n>und storage tanks from thesite in I96I3.' Test result§ as pant oftha tank removal fir
<br />h:_~~ nc, toIueue, etbyltei>zeue anti xylenes tR'IBX3 nod total petrolemuhydracurbjlns ('IYII)
<br />tier. ,below dcicction-limits. Hcrscra's Phase Il asscs3ment inctiideda boring to,assess
<br />cr. ~ -i.~ materquality down-gradient afthe Farmer undargronnd stornga tttnk alts. The
<br />C~ oundwdu r sampleddid not indicate coutamtnatiou at the former storage tan}: site.
<br />Cite PinaCF,TS has accurnfdy nrlriressed the'known and unknown couditious Itt~@itt nt ;h~
<br />n lternative 2,'Option A; site in the Hazardoru°;tfaterials - Poterrtlal bfitlgatron d~fean
<br />section. Themtwticbaennocandreionyidentificflforwluc6ica.QOnablcmitigatiunmc,-,i.ti.~
<br />cciuld not liedevetoped as stated in i6e RIS. There is one small conectlon thnt shopid'r_ nra < to
<br />the Potentta('~S4iligaritin"~bfeasruessection(paga 103}. ]n the state of Oregon, clispcrsalanii
<br />treahncnt facilities fosFie;truleum-coidamin3ted soils un; reguiatetl by tlir+ Ur~gntfI3epurtm_at ,~S
<br />bnvirottmetif~l Quality (not county public hcaltii departttiohts}. Thero me several of t? ease
<br />fiiaihtics Iopatcd in Oregon. -
<br />'T'he City of Fugate support; efforts to mhtimizethe ctfectson water anti biological iesoar. n
<br />dunngconstrucnonandtilx-ratiunofihenetrcoiut6ouse;:aticlh<IiavestliattheC~>iyui~site
<br />'.. often stimaadvantagee.ThcE[S.indtcatesthaChabiialforLhreatcnod'aridendo-u~garedfislt
<br />species is not7ikely to Ile a€ieair~d at tlilssite. The eaistenceoYthe raikoadpteveuts os*erl.rr .
<br />? llnw of stormwatcrtx ttvixn tftesite and the river. rWditioaGtiy, the sitCis htghlyurbt~ie.: t:~ar
<br />m icr-emovalnu.es;firyUasedontheprelimmatycowtnousefooq~rint.
<br />J.lrsA~na~si~st11lrr~IResnumes
<br />I ue Altcrttatit~e 2, OptionsA and&utiJirethctivestem purtionolthe Chiquita site.=c . , ,~: n~,:
<br />ct the eourthause on thewesterd portion of th@ Ghignita site is preferrgd because itr i .
<br />integrates Elie conft3YoiL~ with dasentown. the }`final HIS Safes tha[tlic Cluquita s1... tc„1 a kilt
<br />in an adverseimpncf to the Ay*ripac Oliicc (749'Fcrry Street} which =~ )tt+ n1, I cli iF' I
<br />IistingontticAingotiaLKegistern€tlistoriaPieces. AneStecftvelu• tic „ricr.:~.tf,,.~r.;~,
<br />recommciida[ion is nqt evident."Inaddition tn`lha mitigation meast,res f.~poa~.~..a,,,~ ~u., i rc
<br />the Agnpnc'Oll'zce 6tiilding, ifis zecommended dwt the entiie Chiqtuta site be documented Stith
<br />Yagc 3 of 7
<br />h ,I quality black dndwhitephotographsf and evaluutec~ ~r tueasared dmwings,.or artifack
<br />r~I~~~ion,nhnuldit[ieptopo>edforcemovel.
<br />Based on archeological mvestigatioas in the dow~ttow~i area, it is pc?ssit+t~+h~t eYcavrti.,ne r+i
<br />tlussitewillunenithhistorictutifecisspanningHugcna'sdcvelnpmenthi te~6-o~ntrel;l%G_u-.
<br />~rhe 1950s.'Fhe City of fiu}*ene sat,horts the EIS recommendation tt+`st ar h ~1logie l i ,:,,r
<br />''h0 an i ILCJ',rtEl oompope~.. -t ;itc r.eavatiun5: -: -
<br />.Other histarie sites intlze area arelduttttied in the CIB, r+s itulit.;e 3 by the State Historic
<br />Fraservation tJffice (October I2, 2000 commetiis an the Drag EISt, ~4e eL3ect ou these propc~ttfcs
<br />could be mitigated through t}tonglitfitl end scpsitive design of the netiv cotuthouse building, end
<br />~ ~? . ,c> of historic ites in the-area cciuld he accomplished by utilizing the western portion of
<br />.ECniya~otsitc.
<br />~ ul~~~i~ i°.t~orpret4vc sigiiv That explain fhe history of the area would help preserve the SLte's "
<br />< < , ,~~._ C'ity sfa}i concws witli4tte recommendatirnt tluitifte Oregon State IIistorie Preservation
<br />t ~ (rug , .fortes Hutuick. is eonsuitui hetitre actions aretakat that af3'eet tits historic resources
<br />uitnin :;n' area.
<br />1r.3ns~urt~tiun
<br />~cAS utdicafed iv the Final kIS, the new eourthoiise would inuw c , rJcrur~ 4n ~~.unm:_ in tL;
<br />...;.vicinity nfthe projcct.'Ihe CttygfEugenu siilipons fhe cot ::~w~,r.i ohm t},c ChiGUUa ::its woul.t
<br />not rc alt in a nignifieant shortage of parking andthai ti,e Site tu; adaqunte 1 ~~a::it,~ to mc:
<br />-' uihiimumilemand,~ttcludtngpAtking reyuiiei(.by colir?h,~n,e~ empleyeca,
<br />TheFinal?;ISisenaec~ , ~r.prea;ntationoftheeui,cnto~ e.i~r~c<,~~ur.=-el:hc Ireutnd
<br />stbnalnet3vetrkaromtdthestb:. Sin.e:cympietii>nofthcFat,~;5trectDu :.~,,>uc i-,cmp~:,ject
<br />in earl}' 2,060, traffiGptnblrm, I cr: e beEn elimbtated. Thc't ~ ~ ~ o scd co u r he-i i s~o w~u ul d nc~ t
<br />signifieantlychangethissafistuetaryuperatioti; TheFipatElSadagitiii ly:.a.t~a~ c~siin?
<br />"conditinn»and impacts; The City tutticipaics jointp}antftng efforts vintl ~ ~ti:1 to :u.i _es t,aIlla
<br />flow+md connectivity fu downtown. Addtftonal comtnenfs un fhe EI9 n~i iii .. ~:h;sis era
<br />pravidadin the attached memo from the City's TraflicEngineer.
<br />itliditir~
<br />1.,. r cal t1S only addresses the consirucfiunHndopi~rafio.ta unp,.ot~ ~n ct litic_,. Hnti :e., it
<br />~ yid to mentioned tttatihe Eugene Watcr6tiBiect~aIloard (F'R'cFil ~ i ,rtic;i+t-d th ~ tn~-
<br />t auu„ire has eniure dependa6leuatersupply thane]sewhere in the t, .,n ar_u l i.c sii~~ ~~1:~~,
<br />has escelIent mower raYlundancy and excellehf y~l, to du;" fiber aptie cent s:;.
<br />There ore tvvo Citf~-owned tdecommunieahonfiberntns ~4b frbe~ and 1 ~ tiCYrt a:u.r tl.c r ilrt~,ri
<br />imntediatalyadjacanttotheChiquitasite. TiierearcalsoCity-okned:rJir,.,.;tsu-.~.tejr,ciy
<br />adjacenitnthesito,whichwouldprotddec~5y,cast-effinientconnccti~ tc, :i_lrlit', i.a~~,}_q-C.F
<br />haaFt(yeLmt~tra`(ltoCrunkhrougli'andadjaeettttotF til-.'I'ti~C,}'Cfibcrtac:;Fa:ienrur,ti~ruve;
<br />YagcAoE?
<br />
|